Compare HR software

HollyHR vs CharlieHR

CharlieHR combines core HR with performance, engagement and perks, plus optional support, recruitment and advice. HollyHR is designed for teams of roughly 5 to 100 employees that want a focused HR core and public per-person pricing.

No card, no sales call and no trial clock.

The short answer

Choose HollyHR if your team needs people records, leave, sickness, documents and onboarding, with Free for up to 10 active employees or one public paid price. Choose CharlieHR when performance reviews, engagement surveys, perks, a native integration catalogue, recruitment or on-demand HR support need to be available now.

Charlie's core subscription is monthly rolling, but its other products have different commitments. Recruit has a 12-month minimum and auto-renews; Charlie Grow states 30 days' notice. Compare the complete package and its terms, not only the core band price.

Choose by fit

Which one belongs on your shortlist?

Start with the work you need the software to do, then compare the price.

HollyHR fits when

  • You need a focused HR core for a team of roughly 5 to 100 employees.
  • Free up to 10 active employees or a public £2 price per active employee suits your budget.
  • You want a guided import that reads Charlie's full account export, including employee documents.

CharlieHR fits when

  • Performance reviews, engagement surveys, perks or a native integration catalogue are requirements today.
  • Dedicated setup support, recruitment software or CIPD-qualified HR advice belong in the same purchase.
  • An established product with more than 65,000 users reduces your buying risk.
Price in practice

Per-person pricing versus headcount bands.

HollyHR Free covers up to 10 active employees. Standard costs £2 per active employee per month across the whole active team. CharlieHR uses monthly team-size bands and sells Recruit and Grow separately.

10 active employees

HollyHR
£0
CharlieHR
£47

25 active employees

HollyHR
£50
CharlieHR
£108

50 active employees

HollyHR
£100
CharlieHR
£323

100 active employees

HollyHR
£200
CharlieHR
£431

Monthly prices; competitor prices are before VAT. On HollyHR, volunteers are free while they're records only; a volunteer who signs in counts as a person on your plan. CharlieHR examples use its published core subscription bands without Recruit or Grow. The 1-to-4 list price is £21; check any introductory offer and add-ons at checkout.

Inside HollyHR

Make working patterns part of the employment record.

HollyHR keeps the person's current working pattern, leave, documents and employment changes together, so everyday HR does not depend on a separate spreadsheet.
  • Effective-dated working patterns and current employment history
  • Leave requests, balances and clashes in one shared workflow
  • Export your records and files yourself, any time
Before you switch

Four terms we put in writing.

Whichever supplier you are leaving, these are worth comparing. Each is true of HollyHR today, with its limit.

Cancel Standard online

A System Admin cancels in Plan & billing. Standard runs to the end of the billing period and your records stay readable.

Customers on arranged billing go through HollyHR instead, and Standard can end sooner if payment retries fail. If more than 10 people are counted on your plan when Standard ends, adding people stops straight away and other changes pause after a 7-day grace period, until you are back to 10 or upgrade.

How leaving works

Published prices, no add-on modules

Free up to 10 people, then a published price per active employee: Standard bills everyone, including the first 10. API and MCP reads and signed read webhooks are on Free and Standard.

Approved API writes come with Standard, and MCP writes also need HollyHR to switch them on. More modules are planned, and none is available or priced today.

See the prices

Take your records with you

A System Admin exports covered records and eligible uploaded files from an active workspace, on any plan. Skipped files are listed.

The export doesn’t include sickness and fit notes, custom fields, working patterns, onboarding, holiday allowances or the activity history yet. The export page shows what is covered and what is left out.

See what the export holds

See who's away, not why

Colleagues see approved time away without private details. Open sickness shows as “Sick” only to people allowed to see it.

Pending, rejected and cancelled requests are not shown as team availability.

See Who's away
Feature by feature

Compare the work, not just the checklist.

What each product includes today, row by row.

Price bands, trial and contract

HollyHR uses active-employee pricing after Free. CharlieHR uses one core price for everyone inside each headcount band.

Ongoing free option

HollyHR

Free up to 10 active employees

CharlieHR

7-day trial

No card; the add-ons are not included automatically.

Core subscription

HollyHR

£2 per active employee

One Standard price without headcount bands.

CharlieHR

£21 to £754 per month

Published bands run from 1 to 4 people through 250 or more.

Core commitment

HollyHR

Monthly or annual billing

CharlieHR

Monthly rolling

CharlieHR's billing guidance states no minimum core contract.

Add-on terms

HollyHR

No equivalent add-ons today

CharlieHR

Terms vary by add-on

Recruit has a 12-month minimum. Charlie Grow states 30 days' notice.

Core HR, performance and engagement

The products overlap on everyday HR. CharlieHR already includes more of the employee-experience layer.

People, leave and documents

HollyHR

Included

CharlieHR

Included

Onboarding

HollyHR

Tasks and starter records

CharlieHR

Included

Performance and engagement

HollyHR

Planned

See the roadmap

Not available today.

CharlieHR

Reviews and surveys included

Perks and marketplace

HollyHR

Not offered

HollyHR has no employee discounts or perks marketplace.

CharlieHR

Included today

Support, recruitment and advice

CharlieHR can add people and expertise to the software subscription. Those extras solve different jobs and carry different prices.

Recruitment

HollyHR

Planned

See the roadmap

CharlieHR

From £55 per month

Recruit has a 12-month minimum and auto-renews.

HR advice

HollyHR

Not offered

CharlieHR

Charlie Grow from £200 per month

CIPD-qualified advisers, not employment lawyers.

Advice boundary

HollyHR

No advice service

CharlieHR

UK-based team members

Charlie says Grow advice covers UK-based team members, not freelancers.

Developer access, export and operating proof

Both products document developer routes and self-service export guidance, with different levels of public detail and operating history.

API

HollyHR

Reads on every plan

On Standard, a System Admin can let other tools make changes.

CharlieHR

Company API credentials

CharlieHR's linked endpoint reference was unavailable at this review, so exact resource and operation breadth is unverified.

Webhooks and MCP

HollyHR

MCP and signed webhook events

Events cover changes to people and time off, made in the app or through the API, but not every action in the app.

CharlieHR

Nothing documented

No current first-party webhook or MCP contract was verified for this comparison.

Exporting your data

HollyHR

Organisation archive

A System Admin can export your records and files any time, on any plan.

CharlieHR

XML package

Charlie says its full export includes data and documents and is deleted after one week.

Supplier scale

HollyHR

New in 2026

CharlieHR

65,000+ users

CharlieHR publishes this figure on its About page.

Switching

Moving from CharlieHR to HollyHR?

List the CharlieHR features and add-ons your team uses before comparing subscriptions. Performance, engagement, perks, recruitment, advice and connected systems all need an owner if you move.

Request the full CharlieHR export and download it before the one-week window closes, then add the ZIP to HollyHR's guided CharlieHR import. It brings in people, reporting lines, company setup and documents, and holidays come from Charlie's Time Off reports. You review every change before it is saved. Check permissions and working patterns before ending the old service.

See more CharlieHR alternatives Compare the best HR software for UK small businesses
Questions

HollyHR and CharlieHR

Is HollyHR cheaper than CharlieHR?

At the published prices shown here, yes for teams of roughly 5 to 100 employees. HollyHR Free covers up to 10 active employees. Standard costs £2 per active employee per month across the whole active team. CharlieHR charges £47 for 5 to 14 people, £108 for 15 to 29, £185 for 30 to 49, £323 for 50 to 99 and £431 for 100 to 149. CharlieHR includes more people tools.

Does CharlieHR have a free plan?

CharlieHR's current pricing and signup journey offers a 7-day trial with no credit card, but not an ongoing free plan. HollyHR Free is ongoing for up to 10 active employees and has no trial clock or card requirement.

Is CharlieHR a monthly rolling contract?

The core CharlieHR subscription is monthly rolling with no minimum term according to its billing guidance. The other products differ: Charlie Recruit has a 12-month minimum and auto-renews, while Charlie Grow says it can be cancelled with 30 days' notice. Check every component in the package you buy.

What does CharlieHR include that HollyHR does not?

CharlieHR includes performance reviews, engagement surveys, employee perks and a partner marketplace in its core product. It also sells Recruit and Charlie Grow. HollyHR's performance and recruitment modules are planned and not available today, and HollyHR does not sell HR advice.

Which product has better developer access?

CharlieHR documents company API credentials, but its linked first-party endpoint reference was unavailable when this page was reviewed, so exact resource, operation and webhook breadth is unverified. HollyHR includes API and MCP reads on every plan and signed webhooks for people and time-off changes. On Standard, a System Admin can also let other tools make changes.

Can we migrate from CharlieHR to HollyHR?

Yes. Request Charlie's full account export, download the ZIP within its one-week window, and add it to HollyHR's guided CharlieHR import. HollyHR stages people with their reporting lines, company setup, employee documents and, if you choose, pay history, and holidays come from Charlie's Time Off reports; you review every change before it is saved. Check permissions and working patterns, and plan separately for performance, engagement, perks, recruitment and advice records.

Start free with up to 10 active employees.

Bring your team over from a spreadsheet. There is no card, no sales call and no lock-in. For up to 10 active employees, everyday HR is free.

Import your people data. Export your organisation's people records and uploaded files.